Ny Pizza Baby in Apopka

We ordered the lasagna and lamb gyro. My friend said the lasagna was on point. I will dream about that gyro I had. I haven’t had one that good since I lived overseas. I will definitely be back. I can’t wait to try your pizza next time around.

Either myself or my roommate have ordered from here numerous times and always delicious. Great food. But tonight I ordered a med stuffed meat pizza...and I am so disappointed and dissatisfied. The pizza is dry, has very little meat and cheese. . I know we are going through hard times right now but this is not a way to compensate for them. If it's under new management, then you need to pick up the pace because it definitely doesn't meet the bar.and that truly saddens me.

They don’t deserve a bad review but the pizza was ok but very expensive compared to similar restaurants

I like it however, they need some improvement In regards of providing higher quality food ! They’re ok not very good smthg that you can satisfy your need when you’re too hangry ! Hope their chef can put some more efforts.Especially the cheese fillet steak sandwiches...Food 4 years ago was better! Still ok with it tho !

So I ordered food from this place today via the slice app oh, I ordered boneless wings and onion rings. Upon receiving my food I realized it's been so overcooked and burnt that It can't be eaten so I contact the company that I order through the app apparently they reached out to the store and was told and I quote "this is how they normally prepare their food." So if they considered overcooked burnt food normal might I recommend that everyone that comes here stay away.

First time in and was definitely glad we ordered. Ended up going with the white pizza (large) and it was delicious.

Great pizza, just wish wait time was less than one hour when I ordered my food.

So much flavor & super nice staff. The Calzones are the best!!!!!

Always great food and exceptional service. Love it here!

I wanted to love this local place and heard great things, but they can't seem to meet their quoted online order times even when you pay ahead. We are 0 for 2 here by at least 20 minutes. So they've lost a star for each instance of being late and another star because now I get to hear my husband complain that "being late is disrespecting someone else's time" because I sent him to pick it up. Prices are higher than chain restaurants, but the pizza is better quality and ingredients. I just won't go unless it's walk-in and convenient because I am not okay waiting almost an hour for pizza that's not even being delivered on a Monday night.

Ha!! I’m at a party now with several different couples and crazy enough were sharing horrible experiences we’ve had with NY pizza baby after experiencing the absolute worst service I have ever experienced about 3 weeks ago today we we learned the hosts struggled last night to receive the right order, and by right I mean the correct number, thoroughly cooked and on time..not a whole lot left to mess up, either way needless to say if you’re looking for good pizza and wings they have em unfortunately they aren’t going to get it right. Don’t waste your time you’re just gonna end up hangry

I really wanted to take a minute to write a review for NY Pizza Baby. A few nights ago I was having a terrible night. It was my birthday and I was all alone. I stopped in pretty late and there were two ladies working behind the counter. They saw I was upset and were SO KIND to me! I just wanted to say thank you to those two ladies who went out of their way to acknowledge me and make me feel so much better. They didn't have to do what they did and for that I was truly grateful. The pizza was great and the staff is very friendly. I would definitely recommend this place if you are passing through Apopka!

Delicious meatballs and pizza, highly recommend. Fast delivery too!

We've been frequenting this lil jem off and on since it opened. My kids love it, my coworkers love it. Great lunch specials, friendly staff and always SUPER freshhhh.

Ordered a meatball sub and there were "4" meatballs. They were cut in half!! So in all actuality there were 2 meatballs on a 12' sub! SERIOUSLY?!?!?

Great pizza and friendly cashier! I was given garlic knots to take home and try! For my first time at this location..that alone made me go back for more. Also, no waiting here. Food is prepared quickly and is hot and fresh! Love it!

Only ordered from here twice, but I can safely say that the food is dang good and the prices are fair.Pizzas are large, toppings are fresh, and when I've gone inside, the place is clean and the workers are friendly.Will order from again!

Has consistently become worse. Pizza dough is not even, so when you pick up a slice, half of it falls off because the dough is too thin in the middle. They charge more for a pizza if you ask for LESS cheese. I'm done. Also, they charge $2.50 for a topping whether or not it's a for a whole pie or half a pie. The cashiers are nice.

Food is consistent. Always done when told it will be done. Only negative is the counter lady. Not very friendly but hey maybe she was having a bad day.

This is one of the best pizza I've had sinced I moved to Orlando. You can taste all the good ingredients and everything is freshly made when you order. They have a full menu I have only had the pizza and wings and they are delicious... Highly recommend it

No question about this. For pizza there the best in town period full stop.The staff very nice. The place clean

I guess I got a very little pepperoni on my pizza with no cheese in the middle didn't stick to the box. super bland with no flavor. Brain dead fat cashier was no help......BEWARE THIS PLACE IS HORRIBLE

We buy dinner at least once a week from Pizza Baby. There food is always freshly cooked and very tasty, their cheesecake is sinful good. They get really busy on the phones but that is because they are so good. I don’t care what it is it is well worth the wait.

The food is pretty good but the prices for the lunch menu went up.

Pizza here is very good. I ordered the siclian large cheese pizza online ..... great taste, great sauce. The sauce wasnt to over powering like some places and it wasnt drenched either in sauce. Definitely a new favorite.

Antipasto salad was awful. It was missing the pepperoni, only 2 small slices plum tomato and onion. The lettuce was limp, the ham, salami and cheese were skimpy and tasteless. The price in google maps was 6.95 which was wrong, with tax it was close to $10. Apparently I should’ve ordered pizza but I was really looking forward to a good salad. 2 stars for the young lady who waited on me. Zero stars for the antipasto.

Highly recommended! You can totally order pizza by the slice, and each slice is handmade to order! Lots of great options on the menu, and the food tasted really fresh. It was really good! I will definitely be back. 🍕

Ok this place is not only delicious. The service is outstanding. I came for lunch with my 5 year old son, the lovely lady that took our order sliced our pizza into smaller pieces to make it easier for him to eat, told the cooks to make the pizza warm so it wouldn’t burn his mouth AND put on cartoons so my son was entertained and happy. Did I mention the food was delicious? He ate a whole slice plus a half and my gyro and fries was fresh, hot and yummy (also huge). Great place to bring the whole family. Love it!

This was our first trip... It was way above my expectations! The pizza is amazing.. but the garlic knots.. I says a HOT DAMN! These bad boys will surprise ya! They'll brighten your day.. Only issue I had, was that I ate entirely too much!

They have great pizza 🍕 He said It's super duper yummy.

Make sure you have time. This was our first time being a customer and we waited over 40 minutes just to get 4 slices of pizza. The pizza was okay but I would not go there again without ordering over the phone then leave the house 30-40 minutes later to arrive on time for the pick up. What if there was a lunch hour rush? They would not be able to handle the customers. They need to do better with time.

Very well organised and accessible restaurant. They serve large meals and for affordable prices. We liked the meals very much and the staff members were super welcoming and explanatory. Recommended.

This place was disgusting for my first and last time ordering from there. I threw away the gyro I ordered which had no sauce on it or on the side and was soggy with brown lettuce on it. So I didn’t get to enjoy that at all. Also i ordered a cold cheese pizza that tasted like it had little to no processed cheese on it. But I made myself eat it so that $30 wasn’t totally down the drain. Last but not least the cold and hard zeppoles which had no sugar powder on them at all. I threw those away also. I’m glad this business mad a profit on my behalf. It’s a no brainer to never order from there again!

The worst experience ever! I called to pick up 2 pies of pizza and waited for an hour. Watched 8 people pick up and leave. Not fair. I’m from NY and I never waited this long for 2 pies.

They are a little pricey for the product. Also, I am willing to spend the extra because 80% of the time they are pretty much the closest and best pizza that delivers to our location. Tonight’s order was pretty bad though. The large pepperoni barely had enough to cover the slices. The large cheese was over stretched and had a hole that they sent out , covered it with melted cheese till you lift the slice and a chunk of it is missing. Just sloppy I expected better for 16$ each.

Hit or miss. This is how our pizza came out. It should be uniform.

Its the best pizza I town!

Food is good. Cooks are good. Servers are ok work hard but they talk extremely loud I mean loud loud good if your hard of hearing bad if you just want a pizza to go quietly not going to happen.Casual setting casual dress they have a 24 inch pizza awesome .servers are sure to say your name extremely loud and what you're ordering everybody will hear if you don't mind that it's good to go

Amazing place and amazing pizza the employees are really nice they pizza is really big and taste so wonderful make me wanna repeat a lot time

Great pizza. This place never disappoints.

I hardly every write reviews but this pizza was awful. Took an hour and a half to get here. It was ice cold, so thin and dry, and tasteless. I’m from NY and I promise you this tastes nothing like NY style pizza. So disappointing.

First time ordering. Received a nice flyer on my door, very decorative. Ordered pizza and boneless wings with their coupon. Pizza was ordinary, nothing to great, boneless wings were good though, honey mustard. Also ordered calamari. But it was unusually tough and on rotten lettuce. Ordered their supreme Philly. My pics show their "supreme" not much of a Philly but is what it is for different restaurants. At least the person who took my order was very clear so I appreciate that part, the food quality was basic, mediocre. Will not order from or recommend to friends.

They make some really beautiful food, was amazing, would recommend to everyone.

Pizza and wings are awesome! Always on time, and great customer service!

So good!!! My go to for good thin crust cheese pizza!! Meat lovers hand tossed is amazing as well... always friendly staff, a decent sized dining/waiting area with TVs, beer and wine!

A little hidden gem in Apopka. Good pizza at reasonable prices

My wife and I want to complement Melissa and Tina for their excellent service. Above and beyond. The food selection exceeds expectations ... especially those delicious wings! 😃

Well my pizza was burned...I didn't see any garlic on the tables. That's just me being ehhh...I am quite sure it wasnt intentional. I am from NY and it didn't remind me of the Big Apple. However that was my first and last impression.

Food was amazing, delivery driver was very fast way ahead of time, and was very nice.

I have always like the recipe here but the service was lacking ever since Ms Tina came along you can actually see the difference in the service, it is spectacularly awesome and the food continues to be great. I guess now we have the perfect combination. I am looking forward to being able to come by for many more years and have Ms. Tina here to receive that excellent service because you can see she cares about the customers.